The Law Office of Neal H. Sobol

PERSONAL INJURY

Premises Liability
Slip and Fall

SETTLEMENT: $101,000.

CASE/NUMBER: Case I.D. Confidential

COURT/DATE: L.A. Superior Central .

JUDGE: Hon. Thomas Murphy, Dept. B

TECHNICAL EXPERTS: Plaintiff – Jay Preston, safety engineer, L.A

Defendant – John Tyson, forensic engineer, Encino.

FACTS: The Plaintiff, a 38-year-old grocery store bakery clerk, slipped and fell on an exterior concrete stairway at a residential apartment complex owned by Defendant. The stairway was wet with water.

CONTENTIONS: The plaintiff claimed strict liability caused by a latent defect due to non-conforming stairs and lighting. Plaintiff further contended that Defendant’s negligent maintenance of the property allowed water accumulation on the stairs from its sprinkler system, constituting a dangerous condition. Defendant contended that the stairway and lighting was according to code; there was no latent defect; and Plaintiff was negligent for failing to use the handrail.

INJURIES: Left heal fracture requiring surgical fusion of subtalar.

SPECIALS IN EVIDENCE: MEDS $23,500; Future MEDS $10,000 to $15,000; LOE (Loss of Earnings) $15,000; Future LOE not determined.

SETTLEMENT DISCUSSIONS: Plaintiff contends he made no demands and Defendant offered $12,500.


OTHER INFORMATION: A prior arbitration by Michael J. Zuckerman resulted in a Plaintiff’s award in the amount of $33,000; trial de novo by Plaintiff. This case settled after 5 days of trial and during jury deliberation.